Equitable Subordination in Nevada

Nevada is a first-in-time recording state, which means that the lien recorded on real property first has priority over subsequently recorded liens.  Huntington v. Mila, Inc. 119 Nev 355, 357, 75 P.3d 354, 356 (2003).  However, there are exceptions to this rule.  In cases of equitable subordination, a lien recorded first in time can be subordinated to a later-recorded lien.  The issue usually arises when there are several liens on a property and the purchaser fails to identify a junior lien holder.  In certain circumstances, the court will allow the purchaser or subrogee to step into the shoes of the superior lien holder.  The rationale behind equitable subordination is that, to do otherwise gives the junior lien holder an undeserved windfall. Houston v. Bank of Ma. Fed. Sav. Bank, 119 Nev, 485, 490 (2003).

The court will allow equitable subordination if:

  • The subrogee made the payment to protect his or her own interest;
  • The subrogee did not act as a volunteer;
  • The subrogee was not primarily liable for the debt; or
  • The subrogee paid off the entire encumbrance and subrogation would not be unjust to the junior lien holder. 

Mort v. United States, 86 F3d 890, 894 (9th Cir. 1996)(citation omitted). 

Byron E. Thomas, Esq.

Tagged with:
 

The federal government provided new Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP) outreach and communication guidelines for foreclosure actions while evaluating the borrower.  These guidelines provide additional protection for delinquent borrowers who have filed bankruptcy but would otherwise be eligible for HAMP benefits. Some key highlights from the directive include:

FORECLOSURE

  • The servicer must evaluate the borrower’s eligibility under HAMP and determine ineligibility before referring the borrower to foreclosure (or make “reasonable solicitation efforts”).
  • If foreclosure activity has already been initiated, the foreclosure sale cannot occur until after the servicer determines if the borrower is ineligible under HAMP (or makes “reasonable solicitation efforts”).
  • The servicer must give the borrower 30 days to respond to HAMP “Non-Approval Notices” in certain circumstances before conducting the foreclosure sale.
  • The servicer must provide, in writing, to the foreclosure attorney certification that the borrower is ineligible for HAMP before conducting the foreclosure sale.

 BANKRUPTCY

  •  A borrower in active Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy or the borrower’s attorney or bankruptcy trustee can request the servicer to consider the borrower under HAMP.  The servicer can no longer decline the borrower as a “proper exercise of discretion.”
  • If the borrower has been approved on a trial loan modification and files a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13, the servicer may not deny the borrower a permanent modification simply for filing bankruptcy.  
  • If a delinquent borrower has a discharged Chapter 7 and chooses not to reaffirm, the first lien mortgage debt is still eligible under HAMP with the following provision added to the permanent modification agreement: “I was discharged in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy proceeding subsequent to the execution of the loan documents. Based on this representation, the lender agrees that I will not have personal liability on the debt pursuant to this Agreement.”

Homeowners struggling to make mortgage payments or feeling their lender or servicer has not worked with them on a loan modification should call a bankruptcy attorney.  For a copy of the full disclosure, see Supplemental Directive 10-02.

“Cancelled Debt” from a Foreclosure May be Taxable

If the bank foreclosed on your house or you abandoned it, and the lender cancelled your debt, you may receive IRS forms from the lender regarding that cancelled debt.  Your lender may send you an IRS Form 1099-A, Acquisition or Abandonment of Secured Property or an IRS Form 1099-C, Cancellation of Debt.  If you used the debt to purchase, build, or substantially improve your primary residence, that debt may qualify as “acquisition debt,” and be eligible for the Home Mortgage Debt Forgiveness Relief program.  If you have received either Form 1099-A or Form 1099-C, the IRS recommends you review IRS Publication 523 and 525 to determine whether you must include the debt amount on your tax return as income.

This article does NOT constitute tax advice.  If you desire tax planning or assistance, seek a qualified professional.

Carlos L. McDade, Esq.

A New York Times article explains how A HIGH credit score won’t necessarily insulate borrowers from the home-foreclosure crisis.

Read the full story here

bILLSNevada Supreme Court Justice James W. Hardesty announced that more than 3,400 homeowners who received notices of default have requested mediation in the Nevada Foreclosure Mediation Program as they seek to hold on to their homes.  Since the program first began on July 1, 2009, 372 mediations have been conducted and another 805 mediations have been scheduled.  An additional 1,401 cases have been assigned to mediators, who are working to schedule and hold those mediations within 90 days of the notices of default being recorded.  Justice Hardesty announced that the statistics are current as of November 16, 2009

Important Note to Homeowners:  If you receive a “Notice of Default and Election to Sell,” you must sign the application form and mail it with $200.00 in certified funds within 30 days from the day you receive your notice to seek mediation.  You should receive two copies of the application form.  Sign both and mail them in the supplied envelopes.  Mail one copy of the application and your $200.00 certified funds using the supplied envelope addressed to the Nevada Foreclosure Mediation Program Office.  If you do not receive any application forms or envelopes, contact the Foreclosure Mediation Program

Currently, the Foreclosure Mediation Program has 95 mediators who have been appointed by the Supreme Court.  Those mediators have all been through rigorous training designed to teach the mediators the intricacies of the mortgage loan and foreclosure process and some mediation techniques.  Another 80 mediators have been trained recently and the Supreme Court will select from the list of those who successfully completed the training.

Justice Hardesty provided the following statistics regarding the program:

  • Notices of Default filed:                 29,242 (July through October)
  • Requests for mediation:                3,446
  • Mediations conducted:                  372
  • Mediations scheduled:                   805
  • Cases processed and
    ready for mediations
    to be scheduled                               1,402

(All statistics beginning July 1, 2009, and as of November 16, 2009 unless noted)

Carlos L. McDade, Esq.

Mediator

bILLSA bankruptcy court in Pennsylvania recently ruled on an issue that has been a frequent source of confusion to those working with short sales. 

The issue is whether a 1099-C issued by a lender to a borrower automatically relieves the borrower of liability for the debt.  In other words, is a creditor prevented from pursuing collection of a debt for which it has issued a 1099-C pursuant to IRS requirements?

A 1099-C is issued to the borrower by the lender for “cancelled” debt.  This debt generally is taxable income to the borrower.  The exceptions to this have been covered extensively in other articles including that for purchase money debt on a primary residence.

In the case of In re Zilka (407 B.R. 684) the court considered this issue in a situation that did not involve a short sale. Nonetheless, the case is illustrative of what may happen when a court considers the issue in a short sale context. The judge wrote:

[The creditor’s] issuance of the Forms 1099-C did not itself operate to  legally discharge the Debtor from further liability on each of the [creditor’s] four claims. That is because Forms 1009-C, as a matter of    law, do not themselves operate to legally discharge debtors from liability on those claims that are described in the Forms 1099-C.

The court addressed the issue of a taxpayer who has paid tax on cancelled debt that is the subject of the 1099-C.  It found that the issuance of a corrected 1099-C would allow the creditor to pursue the debt in such a situation.  This can be distinguished form a short sale of a primary residence where the owner most likely is subject to tax relief.

Robert B. Noggle, Esq.

Tagged with:
 

Behavioral Economics

ResessionThe pundits are suggesting that the economic recovery will be far slower than they had originally anticipated. Despite the slug of government money and programs, the consumer is the chief factor in determining how deep and how long this recession will be. Despite moderately good news on the stock market and employment sector, consumers remain cautious and are choosing to pare down debt and save rather than extend credit and spend. This is a gloomy picture considering that consumer consumption accounts for roughly seventy percent (70%) of the GDP.

Tisha Black-Chernine, Esq.

Tagged with:
 

Tax Form 982 and Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act

Homeowners whose mortgage debt is partly or entirely forgiven during the calendar years of 2007 through 2012 are able to claim tax relief by filling out the newly-revised Form 982, filing it with the Internal Revenue Service, and submitting it with their year-end federal tax returns. Normally, when a bank gives a homeowner debt forgiveness it results in taxable income. However, the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act of 2007 allows taxpayers to exclude from their taxable income debt forgiven on their principal residence. A homeowner qualifies for this tax exclusion if the balance of their loan is $2 million or less, or $1 million for a married person filing a separate return.

The Tax Form 982 applies to debt reduced through mortgage restructuring, loan modifications, short sales, and foreclosures. Eligible homeowners need only fill out the Form 982 and receive a 1099-C from their lending institution. The debt forgiven by the lending institution must have originated to buy, build or improve the taxpayer’s principal residence and must have been secured by that residence. Debt associated with rental or investment properties, home equity lines of credit, business property, credit cards or car loans do not qualify for the new tax-relief provision.

A homeowner will encounter the Tax Form 982 upon the completion of a mortgage restructuring transaction. This would include but not limited to (1) a successful loan modification with principal reduction, (2) a completed short sale, and (3) a foreclosure sale with remaining deficiency.

If you would like additional information about the Tax Form 982 and its relation to your residential home visit the IRS’ website at www.irs.gov.

James E. Herbe, Esq.

Tagged with:
 

Mission Statement

The purpose of Black & LoBello is to provide exceptional legal services through customized and practical legal strategies.

Notice

The information contained on this Blog is designed to enable you to learn more about the services that Black & LoBello offers to its clients. These materials do not, and are not intended to, constitute legal advice, nor are they intended as a source of advertising or solicitation. Your use of this Blog does not create or constitute an attorney-client relationship. You should not consider these materials to be an invitation for an attorney-client relationship. Further, you should not rely on the information provided on this Blog without first obtaining separate legal advice.

Black & LoBello

Black & LoBello is an AV® Preeminent rated, locally owned, full service law firm in Las Vegas, Nevada.

tel. 702-869-8801

fax 702-869-2669

www.blacklobellolaw.com

10777 West Twain Avenue, 3rd Floor Las Vegas, NV 89135

For a map of our location, click here.